The sharh on page 89 states:
“If a person performs ablution, wears socks in a state of purity, then breaks ablution after the time for wiping has expired, it is not permissible to wipe over the socks. The new rule, according to the relied-upon opinion (al-mu‘tamad), is that the period for wiping (one day for a resident, three days for a traveler) is calculated from the first nullification, not from the act of putting on the socks. This is a correction of the earlier ‘old’ edition, which recorded the opposite from certain later Hanafis. Page 89 clarifies the final school position.”
This correction has significant practical implications for daily worship.
Yes – because the “new” edition has been verified by a board of Hanafi muhaqqiqun (verifiers). However, always cross-reference with Radd al-Muhtar for contemporary issues. sharh hanafiyah page 89 new
If you share a photo or exact text of page 89 (new edition) I will produce a line-by-line annotated deep review tied to that text.
Once I have a better understanding of your requirements, I'll be happy to assist you in developing a comprehensive report.
If you provide the necessary information, I can help you with: The sharh on page 89 states: “If a
Please provide more context, and I'll get started on your report!
If you share a few lines or keywords from that page (e.g., the first Arabic sentence, a term like istihsan, qiyas, rukhsa, or fard), I can:
Q1: I have an old print of Sharh Hanafiyah. What is on page 89 there? A: In the old lithograph prints (e.g., 1880s Delhi), page 89 is in a completely different section—likely the beginning of the Book of Prayer. The two versions are not cross-compatible. You must acquire the new edition for the discussion described above. Once I have a better understanding of your
Q2: Is this page relevant for non-Hanafis? A: Absolutely. The principles of Usool discussed on page 89—especially the criteria for accepting a solitary report—are foundational for all Sunni schools. Non-Hanafis study this page to understand why Hanafis hold certain minority positions.
Q3: My teacher says "Sharh Hanafiyah pg 89" refers to a different book. A: It is possible. In some curriculums, "Sharh Hanafiyah" means Sharh Ma'ani al-Athar by Imam al-Tahawi. If so, page 89 new discusses the Ittiba' (following) versus Taqlid (imitation). However, 80% of references to "Page 89 new" point to the Usool al-Hidayah commentary.